ADMIN

She told an immigration judge police kept beating her husband.

Her husband had been dead for years.

Four members of Congress just named a bill after her story. 🧵


The bill is Rep. Lateefah Simon's, with Reps. Garamendi, Lofgren and Vargas. Introduced Nov. 19.

Simon's release names its inspiration: "Ms. Harjit Kaur." Garamendi made her his State of the Union guest and called her a grandmother "deported despite following the law."
Now the court record. Shanta v. Holder, 9th Cir. No. 08-72386 (Dec. 11, 2012).

The caption: "HARJIT SHANTA, AKA Harjit, AKA Harjit Kaur, AKA Sarabjit Kaur." Native of India, final appeal lost in 2012. Her own family's campaign site lists the same aliases.

cases.justia.com/federal/appell…

She told an immigration judge that Indian police repeatedly arrested and abused her husband after she fled.

Then she admitted her husband "had been killed several years before she left India."

Her explanation: she meant her boyfriend, "just the image of [her] first husband."
The boyfriend testified. He was arrested for his own politics. He was never at her house when police came.

And she "suggested he adopt her husband's name of Sukhwinder to gain benefits under her asylum application."

The Ninth Circuit's words: "This fraud."
The coverage skips this part: she was GRANTED asylum.

It unraveled when she petitioned to bring a relative over. That triggered an overseas investigation, and the BIA terminated her asylum for fraud. The court: she "clearly previously presented falsified documents."

An immigration judge found it. The BIA terminated her asylum over it. The Ninth Circuit upheld it.

None of that is in the sponsors' press release. "No criminal record" means nobody convicted her. It doesn't mean she followed the law.
Now the bill. Section 2: "Each final order of removal shall expire on the date that is 10 years after the date on which such order was issued."

Each. No conviction screen at that step. The "no criminal record" line only kicks in later, for who can petition for status.
Want to keep an order alive? DHS has to go to a judge with "clear and convincing evidence" of a delay "unrelated to administrative or funding delays," plus "new evidence" that renewal serves the public interest.

A fraud finding already sitting in the file isn't new.
Who gets shut out of status? Only people convicted of a crime punishable by more than a year.

A fraud finding isn't a conviction. And the green card section lists orders based on INA 212(a)(6)(C), fraud or willful misrepresentation, as eligible. Fraud isn't a bar. It qualifies.
Asylum fraud is a federal crime under 18 U.S.C. 1546. I found no record she was ever charged. She should have been.

The government took the shortcut and assumed removal would follow. It didn't. 13 more years.

Now four members of Congress want to turn that failure into a green card.
I spent my career in immigration enforcement. Asylum is for people who tell the truth about persecution. She lied.

Put a court-documented fraud case on the poster and the message is simple: lie, run out the clock for 10 years, apply for a green card.

Read it yourself:

@Jim_Jordan @HouseJudiciary @Phase2Deport @ItsYourGovsimon.house.gov/sites/evo-subs…
• • •

 

 

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/2123915519984025799.html

You need to be a member of Patriot Command Center to add comments!

Join Patriot Command Center

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Not a lie that they don't support. 

This reply was deleted.