Texas Rep. Chip Roy recently took to the House floor as Republicans were still sorting out the midterm results. "No one stood on the wall at the Alamo shouting, I want 3.9 percent economic growth," he said. "We're a nation, we're not an economy." Roy added that the Founders were not talking about earnings per share or Wall Street, and that those who pledged their lives, their fortunes, and their sacred honor were not doing so for corporate interests.
Townhall writer Dmitri Bolt took issue with that argument in a November 16 column. Bolt says Roy is treating economic prosperity and national flourishing as if they were competing goals. In Bolt's view, that is a misunderstanding of what allows a nation to flourish.
Bolt writes that companies exist to provide goods or services and to earn a profit by making them better or cheaper. He argues that while a nation and its economy are not the same thing, a nation cannot flourish without economic prosperity.
He also says the Founders cared deeply about American prosperity. Bolt points to Thomas Jefferson's first inaugural address, where Jefferson said a wise and frugal government should leave people free to pursue their own industry and not take from labor the bread it has earned. Bolt also notes that Alexander Hamilton called commercial prosperity "a primary object" of a statesman's attention.
Bolt does grant part of Roy's concern. He writes that Republicans have too often defended particular businesses rather than economic freedom, and that crony capitalism has done real harm. But he says that is no excuse to punish corporations, dismiss growth, or walk away from economic freedom. In Bolt's view, economic freedom is not only a source of prosperity. It is a safeguard against tyranny.
Here is how I see it. Chip Roy is right that a country is more than a balance sheet. Faith, family, law, and liberty are what make a people a nation. At the same time, Bolt is right that those things are hard to keep if families cannot earn a living and keep what they earn. A strong nation and a free economy should serve each other, not be set against each other.
Patriots have always held both of those truths.
Was Rep. Chip Roy right to say we are a nation, not an economy? Or is economic freedom, as Dmitri Bolt argues, at the foundation of our national strength?
Not a member yet? Join here for free membership! Click -> [JOIN]
50,000 members and growing!
Members: Please give your opinion in the comment section below.
Replies