A Warning Letter to Senator Warren

31309170885?profile=RESIZE_400xOn November 15, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, Aaron F. Reitz, sent an unusual letter to Senator Elizabeth Warren. It is a formal "preservation demand." It tells the Senator to save all documents, communications, and electronic records tied to what the letter calls her plan to weaponize congressional investigations against private Americans who associate with President Trump.

The letter points to Warren's own words. After the midterms, she told Face the Nation that big tech CEOs, Wall Street executives, and large corporations "better get ready for some investigations, serious ones." It also cites her Time op-ed and recent letters she sent with Senator Blumenthal, Senator Slotkin, and Representative Garcia demanding information from private citizens and companies with ties to the President.

Reitz reminds her that congressional investigations must serve a real legislative purpose. Quoting the Supreme Court, he writes that investigations done only to "punish" those investigated are "indefensible." He also points to the First Amendment's protection of the right to associate freely. He asks her to confirm in writing by November 23 that she has received the letter and is preserving the records.

The letter is getting a lot of attention, and law professor Orin Kerr (@OrinKerr) raised a point many people missed. The letter lists two criminal laws, 18 U.S.C. 241 and 242, which deal with conspiracy against rights and deprivation of rights under color of law. But the warning near the end, about "sanctions" and "adverse-inference instructions," is language from civil lawsuits. Civil cases have a specific rule, Rule 37(e), about preserving electronic records. Kerr says he knows of no matching preservation rule in criminal cases, though obstruction of justice laws apply to everyone.

In plain terms, Kerr is asking whether this letter is mainly a legal tool or mainly a public warning shot. Either way, the message is clear. Powerful members of Congress have spent years using investigations to go after people who support President Trump. Now someone in the Justice Department is telling them their own conduct is being watched, too.

Many Patriots will see this as overdue. Congress has real oversight duties, but those duties are not a license to harass private citizens for who they support. Others will wonder whether the letter has legal teeth or is mostly a signal. What comes next, starting with the November 23 deadline, will tell us a lot.

Should prosecutors push back when members of Congress threaten private citizens with investigations? Or should this fight be settled at the ballot box?

Not a member yet? Join here for free membership! Click -> [JOIN]

50,000 members and growing!

Members: Please give your opinion in the comment section below.

You need to be a member of Patriot Command Center to add comments!

Join Patriot Command Center

Email me when people reply –