ADMIN
Can the NAACP sue under the Clean Air Act to stop @spacexai from building a brand new "colossal" power plant in Mississippi--which would play a key role in lower electric bills? Yes, for now, per a federal district judge. But, for several reasons, I'm skeptical. Let's dive inImage
@spacexai What's the object of dispute? Basically, SpaceX is building a large plant-- > a gigawatt, which equals what could power 1 million homes. In the meantime, they've put in turbines, solar, and power banks to produce significant energy without raising anyone's bill "behind the meter"Image
@spacexai At the start, an interesting legal issue. Is the NAACP a "person" with standing to vindicate rights under the Clean Air Act? Embracing a form of corporate personhood often attacked by NAACP's allies (think Citizens United), the Court finds statutory associational standing. Maybe!Image
@spacexai On the merits, Mississippi has federal obligations relating to permitting for permanent power plants. Those rules seem to be followed. But what about the temporary turbines at issue now? The judge interprets the law to include them--seemingly contrary to MS's SIP. I'm skeptical!Image
@spacexai SpaceXSI also challenges the constitutionality of the Clean Air Act's Citizen Suit section. Its a very interesting argument, the district judge doesn't want to reach the private nondelegation issue. I also wonder if MS can assert its own rights to preempt the suit? Interesting!Image
@spacexai Normally, a motion to dismiss denial can't be appealed. It's an interlocutory order. My understanding is that SpaceXSI has already moved to certify the appeal. Seems like a good candidate, given the multiple important and novel issues.
@spacexai Read the full order here;: earthjustice.org/wp-content/upl…

• • •

By:31309326059?profile=RESIZE_584x

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/2122063835117101350.html

E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of Patriot Command Center to add comments!

Join Patriot Command Center