Here is a number that should stop every clinician in their tracks.
When you compare what people say against what their urine test shows, around one in three who test positive for amphetamines reported no use at all. A third of them. Looked the doctor in the eye, and the drug was already in their blood.
That is not a character flaw. It is the single most important fact about how we assess these people, and the whole system is built to ignore it.
I spent twenty-six years telling professionals whatever got me the outcome I wanted, and I have watched thousands do the same since. I am not saying everyone but does but it works like this.
The same man, the same week, walks through four doors. He tells the counsellor about his feelings, because that keeps the counsellor on side. He tells the parole officer everything is stable, because the parole officer holds his freedom. He tells the judge he is full of remorse, because the judge holds his liberty. He tells the doctor the symptoms that get him what he came for, and leaves out the drug that would complicate it.
Four versions of one man, each tuned to the person in the room.
He is not evil for this. When you grow up in chaos, you learn young that honesty gets you hurt and performance gets you through. By the time he is sitting in front of these professionals it is not a trick. It is the only way he has ever known to stay safe.
Now look at what we do with it.
We run the entire diagnostic system on self-report, on what the person says about themselves. And we aim that method at the one group on earth trained since childhood to say whatever gets them through the door.
The counsellor writes up their version, the doctor diagnoses off theirs, and because nobody holds the whole picture, nobody ever lays the four stories side by side and sees they do not match. A diagnosis gets built on a performance. A story told to survive a five-minute appointment becomes a label worn for life.
The research has known for decades that self-report in this population is unreliable. One in three denying a drug that is in their urine is not a surprise to anyone who studies it. And still, the interview in the room is treated as the truth.
The answer is not to call these people liars. It is to stop trusting one interview in one room. Test. Gather the history. Talk to the family. Give it time. The truth is findable. It is just not sitting in a single conversation with a man who learned to perform before he learned to read.
You cannot assess a drowning man by asking him if he can swim.
Cold hard facts. Sourced. Corrected when wrong.
What's your thoughts…?
Peter Lyndon-James 🇦🇺
Sources:
Murrie, Lappin et al, transition of substance-induced psychosis to schizophrenia, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 2020 (Australian-led NDARC meta-analysis, 50 studies); Wilcox et al, self-report vs urine drug screen concordance, Addictive Behaviors, 2013; Bramness et al, amphetamine-induced psychosis, BMC Psychiatry, 2012; Hong, psychosis in borderline personality disorder, The Hospitalist; Rice et al, family history method vs direct interview, 1995. The transition study is Australian; the remaining clinical figures are from international literature, the facts apply here but the research was done overseas.
HOT POTATO 2 - ONE IN THREE DENY THE DRUG THAT'S IN THEIR URINE. WE DIAGNOSE THEM ANYWAY. Here is a number that should stop every clinician in their tracks. When you compare what people say against what their urine test shows, around one in three who test positive for amphetamines reported no use at all. A third of them. Looked the doctor in the eye, and the drug was already in their blood. That is not a character flaw. It is the single most important fact about how we assess these people, and the whole system is built to ignore it. I spent twenty-six years telling professionals whatever got me the outcome I wanted, and I have watched thousands do the same since. I am not saying everyone but does but it works like this. The same man, the same week, walks through four doors. He tells the counsellor about his feelings, because that keeps the counsellor on side. He tells the parole officer everything is stable, because the parole officer holds his freedom. He tells the judge he is full of remorse, because the judge holds his liberty. He tells the doctor the symptoms that get him what he came for, and leaves out the drug that would complicate it. Four versions of one man, each tuned to the person in the room. He is not evil for this. When you grow up in chaos, you learn young that honesty gets you hurt and performance gets you through. By the time he is sitting in front of these professionals it is not a trick. It is the only way he has ever known to stay safe. Now look at what we do with it. We run the entire diagnostic system on self-report, on what the person says about themselves. And we aim that method at the one group on earth trained since childhood to say whatever gets them through the door. The counsellor writes up their version, the doctor diagnoses off theirs, and because nobody holds the whole picture, nobody ever lays the four stories side by side and sees they do not match. A diagnosis gets built on a performance. A story told to survive a five-minute appointment becomes a label worn for life. The research has known for decades that self-report in this population is unreliable. One in three denying a drug that is in their urine is not a surprise to anyone who studies it. And still, the interview in the room is treated as the truth. The answer is not to call these people liars. It is to stop trusting one interview in one room. Test. Gather the history. Talk to the family. Give it time. The truth is findable. It is just not sitting in a single conversation with a man who learned to perform before he learned to read. You cannot assess a drowning man by asking him if he can swim. Cold hard facts. Sourced. Corrected when wrong. What's your thoughts…? Peter Lyndon-James 🇦🇺 Sources: Murrie, Lappin et al, transition of substance-induced psychosis to schizophrenia, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 2020 (Australian-led NDARC meta-analysis, 50 studies); Wilcox et al, self-report vs urine drug screen concordance, Addictive Behaviors, 2013; Bramness et al, amphetamine-induced psychosis, BMC Psychiatry, 2012; Hong, psychosis in borderline personality disorder, The Hospitalist; Rice et al, family history method vs direct interview, 1995. The transition study is Australian; the remaining clinical figures are from international literature, the facts apply here but the research was done overseas.
— Peter Lyndon-James (@PeterPerthWA) November 16, 2026
Comments