The Department of Labor just made a remarkable admission about the labor market test used to sponsor foreign workers for green cards.
Under the existing PERM system, employers conducted recruitment, prepared reports and documented why American applicants were rejected - but there was a catch.
The underlying recruitment packets, including advertisements, resumes and rejection justifications, generally stayed with the employer.
They were only submitted when DOL specifically requested them, typically during an audit.
DOL acknowledges that officers certified applications:
“in the vast majority of circumstances without having reviewed the employer’s consideration of U.S. workers”
Now consider DOL’s own FY2021–FY2025 findings:
- 409,368 professional-occupation labor certifications approved.
- Approximately 76% of employers in the analyzed groups chose local or ethnic newspapers for recruitment.
- Of 387,518 applications using online job boards, 241,880 (62%) advertised for fewer than 15 days.
- Just 0.2% used job fairs.
- Just 0.5% used on-campus recruitment.
So - employers were required to establish that qualified American workers were unavailable. They controlled the recruitment, evaluated the applicants, documented the rejections and generally retained the evidence themselves and DOL then routinely issued certifications without examining that evidence.
Now DOL proposes requiring employers to submit the recruitment packets with every application. This is an overdue reform, but it raises a much bigger question:
How many of the hundreds of thousands of previously approved labor certifications would survive an independent examination of the actual recruitment evidence?
Congress should demand a retrospective, risk-based audit of historical PERM certifications, examining whether employers complied with the requirements in effect when those applications were filed.
New rules - no matter how thankful I am for them, won’t absolve old violations.
The Department of Labor just made a remarkable admission about the labor market test used to sponsor foreign workers for green cards. Under the existing PERM system, employers conducted recruitment, prepared reports and documented why American applicants were rejected - but there was a catch. The underlying recruitment packets, including advertisements, resumes and rejection justifications, generally stayed with the employer. They were only submitted when DOL specifically requested them, typically during an audit. DOL acknowledges that officers certified applications: “in the vast majority of circumstances without having reviewed the employer’s consideration of U.S. workers” Now consider DOL’s own FY2021–FY2025 findings: - 409,368 professional-occupation labor certifications approved. - Approximately 76% of employers in the analyzed groups chose local or ethnic newspapers for recruitment. - Of 387,518 applications using online job boards, 241,880 (62%) advertised for fewer than 15 days. - Just 0.2% used job fairs. - Just 0.5% used on-campus recruitment. So - employers were required to establish that qualified American workers were unavailable. They controlled the recruitment, evaluated the applicants, documented the rejections and generally retained the evidence themselves and DOL then routinely issued certifications without examining that evidence. Now DOL proposes requiring employers to submit the recruitment packets with every application. This is an overdue reform, but it raises a much bigger question: How many of the hundreds of thousands of previously approved labor certifications would survive an independent examination of the actual recruitment evidence? Congress should demand a retrospective, risk-based audit of historical PERM certifications, examining whether employers complied with the requirements in effect when those applications were filed. New rules - no matter how thankful I am for them, won’t absolve old violations.
— Nick Plumb (@PlumbNick) November 16, 2026
Comments