Background: We asked Judge Mazzant to reconsider his rulings that the FBI adequately searched for records about Rich and the 2016 DNC email leak. Our motion relies on the FBI’s own files, declassified this summer, which show that the FBI kept the OXFERD COMMA and MARCH TOLL investigations in “prohibited” files that its FOIA searches never reached.
In our reply, we showed that the FBI’s opposition misquoted our FOIA request. We asked for the code names assigned to “individuals” as part of Crossfire Hurricane. The FBI’s brief changed that word to “investigations,” inside a block quotation, and then built an argument on the changed word.
Today the FBI admitted it. It calls the change an “inadvertent transcription error.” Readers can decide for themselves whether -- in an era of cut-and-paste -- a single word gets retyped coincidentally such that it forms the entire basis of one of the FBI's arguments.
The FBI also admitted that it “stated the Crossfire Hurricane binder chronology too broadly.” It had told the Court that the binder of declassified records “did not exist” when it searched. In fact, the binder was delivered to the White House in December 2020, and the FBI kept searching well into 2021.
There is more. The FBI now concedes that OXFERD COMMA and MARCH TOLL were “related to” Crossfire Hurricane. It also says it “has determined” that those files are not likely to contain anything responsive... but it reached that conclusion without searching them, and it still refuses to search.
And one thing is still missing. In 2025 the FBI swore that it would search a previously undisclosed evidence room at headquarters and report what it found. It has now filed four briefs since we raised the issue. Not one of them says what was in that room.
Today's FBI filings are available at the URLs below. #LiarsGonnaLie
http://lawflog.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/show_temp-4.pdf
http://lawflog.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/show_temp-5.pdf
UPDATE in Seth Rich records case: The FBI has now admitted to a federal judge that it misstated the record twice in its last brief. Background: We asked Judge Mazzant to reconsider his rulings that the FBI adequately searched for records about Rich and the 2016 DNC email leak. Our motion relies on the FBI’s own files, declassified this summer, which show that the FBI kept the OXFERD COMMA and MARCH TOLL investigations in “prohibited” files that its FOIA searches never reached. In our reply, we showed that the FBI’s opposition misquoted our FOIA request. We asked for the code names assigned to “individuals” as part of Crossfire Hurricane. The FBI’s brief changed that word to “investigations,” inside a block quotation, and then built an argument on the changed word. Today the FBI admitted it. It calls the change an “inadvertent transcription error.” Readers can decide for themselves whether -- in an era of cut-and-paste -- a single word gets retyped coincidentally such that it forms the entire basis of one of the FBI's arguments. The FBI also admitted that it “stated the Crossfire Hurricane binder chronology too broadly.” It had told the Court that the binder of declassified records “did not exist” when it searched. In fact, the binder was delivered to the White House in December 2020, and the FBI kept searching well into 2021. There is more. The FBI now concedes that OXFERD COMMA and MARCH TOLL were “related to” Crossfire Hurricane. It also says it “has determined” that those files are not likely to contain anything responsive... but it reached that conclusion without searching them, and it still refuses to search. And one thing is still missing. In 2025 the FBI swore that it would search a previously undisclosed evidence room at headquarters and report what it found. It has now filed four briefs since we raised the issue. Not one of them says what was in that room. Today's FBI filings are available at the URLs below. #LiarsGonnaLie https://t.co/AuMAGaNjnU https://t.co/5yNtEFL325
— Ty Clevenger (@Ty_Clevenger) November 19, 2026
Comments