More than three years ago, I began uncovering widespread, systematic fraud and misrepresentation within the PERM green card program.
Using the existing PERM regulations, I conducted an independent audit of labor certification applications from 2020–2024. More than 80% of the applications I audited contained what I identified as fraud, misrepresentation, or regulatory noncompliance.
Employers concealing job opportunities from American workers, manipulating recruitment timelines around layoffs, tailoring job requirements to predetermined foreign beneficiaries, misrepresenting actual qualifications, excluding positions from their own career websites, and creating unnecessary barriers for U.S. applicants. And those examples barely scratch the surface of what I uncovered.
We were repeatedly told America had a skills shortage. Yet the recruitment practices I examined told a very different story. If qualified American workers truly were unavailable, employers should have had no difficulty conducting recruitment openly, fairly, and in good faith. Instead, I uncovered practices that were deliberately designed to exclude, displace, and disregard qualified American workers, not merely deny them a fair opportunity to compete, but ensure they were never genuinely considered for the jobs in the first place.
The long-term harm of PERM goes far beyond the jobs Americans were denied. H-1B was the gateway, but PERM provided the pathway to permanent residency, turning displacement into lasting labor-market competition. The employment-based green card backlog reflects the enormous scale of that pipeline.
This administration has repeatedly acknowledged the fraud and displacement that demand reform. But preventing future abuse is only half the solution. Accountability must also include enforcing existing fraud and inadmissibility laws against those who knowingly participated in these schemes, whether they are awaiting green cards, already permanent residents, or have since obtained citizenship
After years of uncovering and documenting these practices, the Department of Labor's proposed overhaul of the PERM green card program represents a long-overdue acknowledgment of the systemic weaknesses that have allowed this abuse to persist. The first comprehensive reforms in nearly 20 years directly address many of the practices I have spent years investigating and fighting to expose. These changes represent an important step toward restoring the integrity of the labor certification process, strengthening enforcement, and preventing employers from continuing to exploit a system intended to protect the American workforce.
Key proposed reforms:
- Recruitment Standards: Require employers to advertise PERM positions for at least 90 days through legitimate recruitment channels, using practices consistent with how they actually hire workers, not separate processes designed to exclude Americans.
- Greater Transparency: Require disclosure of actual wages, job qualifications, and the number of openings, with detailed records identifying U.S. applicants and the reasons they were rejected. Employers would face greater scrutiny over claims that qualified Americans were unavailable.
- Preventing Layoff-Based Displacement: Establish two-year restrictions following qualifying layoffs of American workers, with continued safeguards to prevent employers from using PERM sponsorship to circumvent those protections.
- Closing Third-Party Staffing Loopholes: Extend protections to certain client-site placements, preventing staffing arrangements from being used to evade restrictions involving displaced American workers.
- Holding Immigration Attorneys and Agents Accountable: Expand DOL's authority to independently investigate and debar attorneys and agents for misconduct, rather than allowing accountability to stop with the sponsoring employer.
- Stronger Enforcement: Expanded audits, employer attestations, and information sharing with DOJ, DHS, EEOC, and DOL's Inspector General.
- Eliminating Outdated Exemptions: Remove certain Schedule A exemptions that allow employers to bypass the standard labor-market test without demonstrating the unavailability of qualified American workers.
These reforms are decades overdue, but closing loopholes is not enough. The laws protecting American workers already existed. Those who knowingly violated them should not escape accountability simply because the government is finally strengthening enforcement. Real reform means stopping future abuse while pursuing those responsible for the fraud, displacement, and harm that have already occurred.
The proposal is open for public comment through January 19, 2027.
https://federalregister.gov/documents/2026/11/17/2026-23370/modernizing-the-labor-market-test-and-improving-protections-for-us-workers-in-the-perm-immigrant
I am sharing examples from my investigations to encourage every American to review these proposed reforms and make their voice heard during the public comment period.
More than three years ago, I began uncovering widespread, systematic fraud and misrepresentation within the PERM green card program. Using the existing PERM regulations, I conducted an independent audit of labor certification applications from 2020–2024. More than 80% of the applications I audited contained what I identified as fraud, misrepresentation, or regulatory noncompliance. Employers concealing job opportunities from American workers, manipulating recruitment timelines around layoffs, tailoring job requirements to predetermined foreign beneficiaries, misrepresenting actual qualifications, excluding positions from their own career websites, and creating unnecessary barriers for U.S. applicants. And those examples barely scratch the surface of what I uncovered. We were repeatedly told America had a skills shortage. Yet the recruitment practices I examined told a very different story. If qualified American workers truly were unavailable, employers should have had no difficulty conducting recruitment openly, fairly, and in good faith. Instead, I uncovered practices that were deliberately designed to exclude, displace, and disregard qualified American workers, not merely deny them a fair opportunity to compete, but ensure they were never genuinely considered for the jobs in the first place. The long-term harm of PERM goes far beyond the jobs Americans were denied. H-1B was the gateway, but PERM provided the pathway to permanent residency, turning displacement into lasting labor-market competition. The employment-based green card backlog reflects the enormous scale of that pipeline. This administration has repeatedly acknowledged the fraud and displacement that demand reform. But preventing future abuse is only half the solution. Accountability must also include enforcing existing fraud and inadmissibility laws against those who knowingly participated in these schemes, whether they are awaiting green cards, already permanent residents, or have since obtained citizenship After years of uncovering and documenting these practices, the Department of Labor's proposed overhaul of the PERM green card program represents a long-overdue acknowledgment of the systemic weaknesses that have allowed this abuse to persist. The first comprehensive reforms in nearly 20 years directly address many of the practices I have spent years investigating and fighting to expose. These changes represent an important step toward restoring the integrity of the labor certification process, strengthening enforcement, and preventing employers from continuing to exploit a system intended to protect the American workforce. Key proposed reforms: - Recruitment Standards: Require employers to advertise PERM positions for at least 90 days through legitimate recruitment channels, using practices consistent with how they actually hire workers, not separate processes designed to exclude Americans. - Greater Transparency: Require disclosure of actual wages, job qualifications, and the number of openings, with detailed records identifying U.S. applicants and the reasons they were rejected. Employers would face greater scrutiny over claims that qualified Americans were unavailable. - Preventing Layoff-Based Displacement: Establish two-year restrictions following qualifying layoffs of American workers, with continued safeguards to prevent employers from using PERM sponsorship to circumvent those protections. - Closing Third-Party Staffing Loopholes: Extend protections to certain client-site placements, preventing staffing arrangements from being used to evade restrictions involving displaced American workers. - Holding Immigration Attorneys and Agents Accountable: Expand DOL's authority to independently investigate and debar attorneys and agents for misconduct, rather than allowing accountability to stop with the sponsoring employer. - Stronger Enforcement: Expanded audits, employer attestations, and information sharing with DOJ, DHS, EEOC, and DOL's Inspector General. - Eliminating Outdated Exemptions: Remove certain Schedule A exemptions that allow employers to bypass the standard labor-market test without demonstrating the unavailability of qualified American workers. These reforms are decades overdue, but closing loopholes is not enough. The laws protecting American workers already existed. Those who knowingly violated them should not escape accountability simply because the government is finally strengthening enforcement. Real reform means stopping future abuse while pursuing those responsible for the fraud, displacement, and harm that have already occurred. The proposal is open for public comment through January 19, 2027. https://t.co/AStVQfug3G I am sharing examples from my investigations to encourage every American to review these proposed reforms and make their voice heard during the public comment period.
— Alb (@amandalouise416) November 17, 2026
Comments