Zohran Mamdani, I have a serious question for you. Who gave you the authority to decide who gets the first opportunity to purchase somebody else’s property?
You didn’t build it. You didn’t maintain it. You didn’t pay the mortgage, property taxes, insurance, or repair bills. You didn’t assume the financial risks associated with ownership.
Yet somehow, government believes it should have a hand in determining how certain property owners conduct their private transactions.
Under New York City’s Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, owners of certain qualifying residential buildings must give approved nonprofit organizations an opportunity to purchase their properties before proceeding with other buyers.
Twenty days to express interest. Another seventy days to submit an offer.
Ninety days of government-mandated procedural interference before the ordinary sale process can proceed.
And we’re supposed to celebrate this as progress?
THIS IS NOT AN ARGUMENT AGAINST AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THIS IS AN ARGUMENT FOR PROPERTY RIGHTS.
Private ownership must mean something beyond having your name on a deed while politicians dictate the conditions under which you can exercise your rights.
The intellectual temerity required to impose additional restrictions on property owners while claiming to solve a housing shortage is extraordinary.
New York already has an affordability crisis. Housing construction is expensive. Property taxes are substantial. Regulatory compliance costs money. And now the government wants to introduce additional procedural obstacles into certain real estate transactions.
Where is the empirical evidence that this will create more housing?
Where is the evidence that it will lower rents?
Where is the evidence that these restrictions will encourage private investment in distressed neighborhoods?
And who ultimately absorbs the additional transaction costs?
I want answers supported by measurable outcomes, not another political speech about intentions.
The most disturbing aspect of this legislation is the underlying philosophy that government should exercise progressively greater influence over assets it does not own.
Today, certain multifamily properties. What prevents tomorrow’s politicians from attempting to expand those restrictions?
A government that genuinely respects private property should have to justify every restriction it imposes upon its owners.
Mr. Mamdani, affordable housing is a legitimate public objective. But a legitimate objective does not automatically justify every method government invents to pursue it.
The burden belongs to you to demonstrate that this legislation improves housing availability without unnecessarily compromising the rights of the people who actually own these buildings.
Because ownership without meaningful autonomy becomes something considerably less than ownership.
And Americans have every reason to question th
at direction.WHEN DID PRIVATE PROPERTY BECOME GOVERNMENT PROPERTY? Zohran Mamdani, I have a serious question for you. Who gave you the authority to decide who gets the first opportunity to purchase somebody else’s property? You didn’t build it. You didn’t maintain it. You didn’t pay the mortgage, property taxes, insurance, or repair bills. You didn’t assume the financial risks associated with ownership. Yet somehow, government believes it should have a hand in determining how certain property owners conduct their private transactions. Under New York City’s Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, owners of certain qualifying residential buildings must give approved nonprofit organizations an opportunity to purchase their properties before proceeding with other buyers. Twenty days to express interest. Another seventy days to submit an offer. Ninety days of government-mandated procedural interference before the ordinary sale process can proceed. And we’re supposed to celebrate this as progress? THIS IS NOT AN ARGUMENT AGAINST AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THIS IS AN ARGUMENT FOR PROPERTY RIGHTS. Private ownership must mean something beyond having your name on a deed while politicians dictate the conditions under which you can exercise your rights. The intellectual temerity required to impose additional restrictions on property owners while claiming to solve a housing shortage is extraordinary. New York already has an affordability crisis. Housing construction is expensive. Property taxes are substantial. Regulatory compliance costs money. And now the government wants to introduce additional procedural obstacles into certain real estate transactions. Where is the empirical evidence that this will create more housing? Where is the evidence that it will lower rents? Where is the evidence that these restrictions will encourage private investment in distressed neighborhoods? And who ultimately absorbs the additional transaction costs? I want answers supported by measurable outcomes, not another political speech about intentions. The most disturbing aspect of this legislation is the underlying philosophy that government should exercise progressively greater influence over assets it does not own. Today, certain multifamily properties. What prevents tomorrow’s politicians from attempting to expand those restrictions? A government that genuinely respects private property should have to justify every restriction it imposes upon its owners. Mr. Mamdani, affordable housing is a legitimate public objective. But a legitimate objective does not automatically justify every method government invents to pursue it. The burden belongs to you to demonstrate that this legislation improves housing availability without unnecessarily compromising the rights of the people who actually own these buildings. Because ownership without meaningful autonomy becomes something considerably less than ownership. And Americans have every reason to question that direction. #AStoneGroove #SilentMajoritySpeaks
— A Gene Robinson (@AlGeneRobi96834) November 16, 2026
Comments